Who Was Murdered and Banished on The Traitors: New Blood? Season 1 Eliminations So Far

Quick answer: Twelve of the 22 players are out of The Traitors: New Blood after nine episodes, counting the Episode 9 murder. Eleven were Faithful and one was a Traitor. Kim Daily, Xavier Scruggs, Logan Smith, Niyyah Hayes (named in Episode 6), Mark Zgoda, Abby Lee in Episode 8 and, in Episode 9, Morgan Cook were murdered; Madeline Kostopulos, Arisa Thomas, Sherry Kuehl and Michael Foote were banished as Faithful. On Thursday, Oct. 29, Tomica Adams became the first Traitor banished, per TODAY and Hollywood Outbreak. Shane Beatty held the Power of the Pardon and used it to spare Victor Vollbrechthausen, so Victor stays in the game. Joe Vanella and Katie Fites remain as Traitors. Episode 9, “Playing Chess,” aired Thursday, Nov. 5 with a poisoned-chalice murder and no banishment; Episode 10 is on Thursday, Nov. 12, at 8 p.m. ET (TVmaze, TODAY).
Who has been murdered and banished so far?
| Night | Player | How they left | Role |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thu., Sept. 17 (Ep. 1) | Kim Daily | Murdered | Faithful |
| Thu., Sept. 17 (Ep. 2) | Madeline Kostopulos | Banished | Faithful |
| Thu., Sept. 24 (Ep. 3) | Xavier Scruggs | Murdered after the recruitment test | Faithful |
| Thu., Sept. 24 (Ep. 3–4) | Logan Smith | Murdered, revealed at breakfast | Faithful |
| Thu., Sept. 24 (Ep. 4) | Arisa Thomas | Banished | Faithful |
| Thu., Oct. 8 (Ep. 5) | Sherry Kuehl | Banished | Faithful |
| Thu., Oct. 8 (Ep. 5, named in Ep. 6) | Niyyah Hayes | Murdered in plain sight; named in Ep. 6 | Faithful |
| Thu., Oct. 15 (Ep. 6) | Michael Foote | Banished | Faithful |
| Thu., Oct. 22 (Ep. 7) | Mark Zgoda | Murdered, revealed at breakfast | Faithful |
| Thu., Oct. 29 (Ep. 8) | Abby Lee | Murdered | Faithful |
| Thu., Oct. 29 (Ep. 8) | Tomica Adams | Banished | Traitor |
| Thu., Nov. 5 (Ep. 9) | Morgan Cook | Murdered (poisoned chalice), revealed at breakfast | Faithful |
That is four completed Round Tables and four wrong answers. Through Episode 6 the Faithful had not caught a Traitor, and every banishment had cost them a teammate rather than the other side a player. The Episode 7 Round Table is the exception to the pattern: it ended with a vote against Victor Vollbrechthausen, per Gold Derby (Jay Vinnedge, Shane Beatty, Tomica Adams, Abbey Benjamin and Joe Vanella voted for him), but Shane Beatty then used the pardon on him in Episode 8, per TODAY and Hollywood Outbreak, so he stayed. Episode 8 ended the streak: Tomica Adams became the first Traitor the Faithful banished. USA Today Network's recap puts the Oct. 8 vote at 11 for Sherry, 5 for Jay Vinnedge and 1 for Michael Foote.
Episode 5 also changed how the murder happened. At a staged funeral, the Traitors had to kill in plain sight by getting a cursed apple to a victim. TODAY and USA Today Network both report that they pulled it off and that the hour ended before the victim was named. Episode 6 then named Niyyah Hayes, per TODAY, USA Today Network and Metro Weekly.
Who are the Traitors on The Traitors: New Blood?
| Traitor | How they got there |
|---|---|
| Tomica Adams | Picked by the host in the premiere; banished in Episode 8 |
| Joe Vanella | Picked by the host in the premiere |
| Katie Fites | Chosen in Episode 3 over fellow accomplice Xavier Scruggs |
This season adds a turret twist. Tomica and Joe named two accomplices, Katie and Xavier, and set them a test: pull a blank death warrant out of a castle book without anyone noticing. Both managed it, the Traitors took Katie into the turret, and Xavier was murdered that same night. TVLine and TODAY both report the same outcome.

What happened on Sept. 24?
Two hours, three players gone. Episode 3 settled the third Traitor and cost Xavier his place. Episode 4, titled "The Death Parade," opened with Logan's murder at breakfast and ended with Arisa's banishment. She had been under suspicion since a conversation with Victor Vollbrechthausen in the billiards room that other players read as a recruitment talk. It was not one, and she left as a Faithful.
| Mission | On offer | What we know |
|---|---|---|
| Episode 3: battering ram and three crypts | $30,000 | Crypts held gold or shields with Traitor information; TODAY reports $15,000 added |
| Episode 4: gold wagon and the death parade | $24,000 | Three gates; four players stayed behind at the first gate |
We have not found two recaps that agree on the running prize total, so we are not printing one. The cap for the season is $250,000.
How did the first banishment go wrong?
Madeline Kostopulos, a construction manager from San Diego, went out on a misheard sentence. Talking with Victor and Kriste Lewis after Kim's murder, she said she would have felt bad about picking Kim. Kriste heard it as an admission, and the Round Table followed her lead. Gold Derby, Parade and NBC's own recap all tell it the same way.
How does a murder or a banishment work on this show?
Each night the Traitors meet in secret and pick one Faithful to murder. The castle finds out at breakfast, when that player does not walk in. The Round Table is the other exit: everyone votes, the player with the most votes is banished, and only then do they reveal which side they were on. That reveal is why the table above has a Role column, and why two Faithful exits in a row matter so much for the Faithful.
The recruitment test is the new wrinkle for this spin-off. Instead of simply offering a Faithful a seat, Tomica and Joe made two accomplices compete for one, and the loser did not get to go back to being a Faithful. That turned a recruitment night into a murder night as well, which is how Sept. 24 produced three exits in two hours.
Money works the same way it does in the main show. Missions add gold to a shared pot, capped at $250,000 this season. If only Faithful are left at the end, they split it; if a Traitor survives to the final, the Traitors take everything.
Who is still in the castle?
By our count, ten of the 22 are still in the game after Episode 9: the eleven listed after Episode 8 minus Morgan Cook. Gold Derby’s pre-episode list of eleven matches that. Here they are alphabetically, with the Traitors marked.
| Player | Status after Episode 9 |
|---|---|
| Abbey Benjamin | In |
| Ben McDonnell | In |
| Clyde Moser | In |
| Jay Vinnedge | In |
| Joe Vanella | In (Traitor) |
| Katie Fites | In (Traitor) |
| Kriste Lewis | In |
| Morgan Cook | Out (murdered, Episode 9) |
| Shane Beatty | In |
| Victor Vollbrechthausen | In (pardoned by Shane Beatty) |
| Wyatt Gillespie | In |
When is the next episode?
Episode 9 aired Thursday, Nov. 5. Episode 10 is Thursday, Nov. 12, at 8 p.m. ET on NBC (TVmaze, TODAY), and the finale is a two-hour episode on Thursday, Nov. 19 (TODAY). Our premiere time guide has the time-zone breakdown and the streaming options.
Over on CBS, Big Brother 28 ended with its Thursday, Oct. 1 finale; our Big Brother start-time page has the last nights. Other elimination shows are tracked the same way: Survivor 51 on Wednesdays, Dancing with the Stars on Tuesdays and The Voice on Mondays. The full autumn calendar is in our fall reality TV guide.
FAQ
Has a Traitor been banished yet?
Yes. Tomica Adams was banished in Episode 8 on Thursday, Oct. 29, the first Traitor out. The four earlier banished players, Madeline Kostopulos, Arisa Thomas, Sherry Kuehl and Michael Foote, were Faithful. Victor Vollbrechthausen was voted out in Episode 7, but Shane Beatty used the Power of the Pardon and he stayed.
How many players are left on The Traitors: New Blood?
By our count ten after Episode 9, down from 22. Morgan Cook was murdered in Episode 9 (no banishment that night); Abby Lee was murdered and Tomica Adams banished in Episode 8; Mark Zgoda was murdered in Episode 7; Niyyah Hayes, the Episode 5 murder victim, was named in Episode 6.
Is The Traitors: New Blood on Oct. 1?
No episode aired that night. Episode 5 aired Thursday, Oct. 8, Episode 6 aired Thursday, Oct. 15, Episode 7 aired Thursday, Oct. 22, Episode 8 aired Thursday, Oct. 29, Episode 9 aired Thursday, Nov. 5, and Episode 10 is Thursday, Nov. 12, at 8 p.m. ET.
Sources
- NBC Insider — "Who Was Murdered and Banished on The Traitors: New Blood?" and the official cast list
- TODAY — Episode 5 banishment and the unrevealed murder
- USA Today Network (NorthJersey.com, via Yahoo) — Episode 5 recap and vote count
- TODAY — Episode 6 murder and banishment
- USA Today Network (via Yahoo) — Episode 6 recap, vote count and players left
- Metro Weekly — Episode 6 recap
- TVLine — Episodes 3 and 4 recap
- TODAY — Episodes 3 and 4 murders and banishments, and the Oct. 1 gap
- NBC Insider — season schedule (weekly Thursdays, Nov. 19 finale)
- TODAY — Episode 7 murder and the power twist
- Gold Derby — Episode 7 recap, vote count and players left
- Reality Blurred — Episode 7 recap
- Gold Derby — Episode 2 recap; Parade — premiere eliminations
- TODAY — Episode 8 murder, banishment and pardon
- Hollywood Outbreak — Episode 8 recap
- TODAY — Episode 9 murder, mission and Episode 10 date
- Gold Derby — Episode 9 recap and players left
- Metro Weekly — Episode 9 recap
- TVmaze — episode titles and air dates (data provided by TVmaze)
- Reality TV Next Week (Sept. 21–27, 2026): The Voice Premieres Monday, Survivor 51 Starts Wednesday, AGT Crowns a Winner
- What Time Is The Traitors: New Blood On Tonight? The Two-Hour NBC Premiere, Explained
- Reality TV Next Week (Sept. 14–20, 2026): DWTS Opens Two Nights, AGT Semifinals, MasterChef Crowns a Winner
- Reality TV This Week, Sept. 7–13 — A Three-Hour AGT, a MasterChef Finale and Two Big Brother Nights